Unlike the learning models that originate from John Dewey’s concept of reflective thinking, such as collaborative learning, cooperative learning, competitive learning, learning by doing, and investigative group learning, the learning by conscience model proposed in this study, instead, is derived from John Dewey’s concept of reflective attitudes. It seeks to introduce a new learning model which is based on the hermeneutic approach while also employing various means of investigation such as descriptive, analytic, and eclectic methods. The study found that there are three variables that correspond to the concept of John Dewey’s reflective attitudes: open-mindedness, whole-heartedness, and responsibility. The study also found that there are four stages of internalization process that must be considered in order to make learning more effective, which include impulse, experience, communication, and action.